Announcing the Winners!

 The winner is...

The Chamber of Frost & Flame by J. Blasso-Gieseke

This dungeon is stupid and delightful. It hits the judgement criteria the hardest of all the entries. The whimsical puzzle-like setup isn't my usual taste in adventures, but I couldn't help being charmed by it. It is a distillation of fantasy adventure; explore, act, suffer the consequences. A $20 gift card has been sent to Mr. Blasso's e-mail. 

This was not an easy choice given the overall high quality of the entries. I shifted the responsbility of further judgement onto the competitors themselves, this time asking them to choose only their favorite adventure. The responses I got showed many struggled with picking a single favorite, and the final tally was close. 

The most popular dungeon as voted by the competitors is...

Cloud-Giant's Cairn by Giant Goose



A narrow but well deserved win! It was the only entry to get 2 votes, proof of the even field. This is a delightful and mature dungeon. By form it reminds me of Gygax's Giant series. It also scored well on the judgement criteria; merciless punishment for the unobservant, great treasures for the brave. A $10 gift card has been sent to Mr. Goose.

Thus concludes the competition!

The entries reviewed so far are all available for download here. A couple of the authors have asked to send updated versions for the final compilation which is going to be a single printer-friendly PDF. Now competitors and observers should use this comment section to gloat, congratulate the winners, and gnash your teeth at the injustice of my judgement. And don't forget to link your other projects and blogs because I am sure some readers are interested to know where these wonderful designs came from.

Comments

  1. ZedSeptember 8, 2024 at 3:02 PM

    Congratulations to the winners and to all fellow competitors too!
    Every entry, even the one that didn't make it, showed clear love for the craft and will be a valuable addition to my game.
    One further entry is yet to be reviewed, if I understood right, hopefully that one will also be a useful addition to my gaming folder.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 21stCentaurySeptember 8, 2024 at 3:18 PM

    Thanks, Olle! A great contest. Delightful dungeons all round. Looking forward to the pdf.

    ReplyDelete
  3. CommodoreSeptember 9, 2024 at 5:17 PM

    Congrats to the winners, and good job on all the entries, I really enjoyed these.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The First Delightful Dungeon Competition

Image
I want to see more delightful dungeons and I want you  to create them! Submit one or more dungeons (or dungeon-like adventuring locations) conforming to the restrictions of the competition before August 26th 2024. A $20 amazon gift card prize is given to the best dungeon as judged by me according to the judgement criteria. A $10 amazon gift card prize is given to the most popular dungeon as voted by the non-disqualified competitors after the final date of submission.  Criteria for qualification Text, maps etc. packaged into a single PDF of no more than 2 pages If printed the details of the text, maps, etc. should be legible (min ~8pt) The dungeon should include at least one of the following themes: hidden treasure, traitors, sentinels The heavy lifting is done by you, don't ask the DM to randomize treasure, come up with hooks, names etc. The dungeon is compatible with an old school system like ACKS, AD&D, B/X, LotFP etc. Criteria for judgement Respect the time, intelligence, an
Read more

Contest Entry: Sharpbone Opal Mine (by Ben Gibson)

Image
The contest's first entry is a strong one, I would definitely run this as a low level adventure or put it on a hex map as a point of interest to run across randomly or by rumor. Download this and keep it in your back pocket (the format allow you to do this literally, you can print it as a double sided paper and run it right off the page!).  Download it here! What follows is the review according to the strictures of the competition. First, does it qualify? Yes.  - While the PDF is technically 3 pages the cover page is not necessary to run the actual dungeon. Nice to see that it has been playtested. I wonder if the playtest prompted any changes to the original form. - I printed it as a double sided paper and read it in low light. The text is completely legible. The map is both small and faint but the details are clear enough that it could be run from the printed page. If I ran it online I would copy the image from the PDF and blow it up for use on VTT where it would be functional, th
Read more